I am a criminal…

January 19, 2011 at 21:06 | Posted in bicycles | 8 Comments
Tags: , , , , , ,

Well, it finally happened. I guess it was inevitable. Riding to work last week I given a ticket by the cops for not wearing a helmet. They were waiting at the foot of the steps at the north end of the Sydney Harbour Bridge, handing out tickets to any cyclist not wearing a helmet. And there were a lot of them – just while I was there they nabbed another three renegade cyclists who dared to take to the streets on a bicycle without wearing a polystyrene hat.

This just seems to me a complete waste of police resources, and I daresay the cops on duty felt the same way. However, their local area command had decided to have a ‘crackdown’ on scofflaw cyclists, so there they were.

I did explain to the office why I don’t wear a helmet; in summary:
– they are unnecessary, as cycling is no more dangerous than walking
– they can actually make things worse in the event of an accident
– they make it more likely that you will have an accident
– there is no compelling evidence that they actually work
– they are hot and uncomfortable and put people off cycling

He listened somewhat sympathetically, but without disputing any of my points said he was there to uphold the law, and therefore he had to give me a ticket. Fair enough. I was of course very polite; funnily enough whilst I was talking to the officer another (helmeted) cyclist came by and started shouting at the police for being so stupid, and that what they were doing was ‘incredibly bad PR’.

I’m less worried about the police’s image than about the many cyclists who, having been given a ticket that morning, will now give up on cycling. This is a great pity for lots of reasons; however one of the most ironic is that fewer cyclists means cycling is more dangerous for those that remain (due to the ‘safety in numbers’ effect). Such is the effect of our ridiculous and misguided helmet laws.

The cops were there again the following week; however on this occasion a kind (helmeted) cyclist coming the other way cross the bridge warned me before I got there. I did consider continuing and getting another ticket (civil disobedience can be, after all, a noble thing). However, on balance I decided I could do without the hassle, so turned back and instead caught the ferry across the harbour – hence the picture. This made for a nice change, although the police had gone by the time I rode past.

So I now have a choice; pay the $57 fine (and get a criminal record), or contest the ticket in court. There is of course a precedent for this; last year a lady called Sue Abbott successfully fought her helmet conviction, arguing (to the satisfaction of a senior judge at Sydney District Court) that wearing a helmet was more dangerous than not wearing one, and thus her actions were protected by a NSW state statute that says people are not compelled to follow laws when doing so would put their lives in danger. I’ll let you know what I decide to do…


RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

  1. Good luck if you take this to court – Sue should be able to help you there.

    In the meantime, let your state member know exactly why these laws are a disaster. There are some template letters here for inspiration http://helmetfreedom.org/


  2. You really get a criminal record for that? I’ve never had a car speeding ticket but that wouldn’t get you a record here (Scotland). I assumed it would be the same sort of thing just sillier.

  3. […] folding concept bike. A look at biking in modern Morocco. An Aussie cyclist is ticketed for riding without a helmet in a police […]

  4. Riding a bike in Australian cities is bad enough, but it’s even worse when you realise that the very people who should be protecting us are just doing lazy and pointless helmet blitzes instead. It’s the classic case of treating the symptoms, not the disease; they’ll make sure we have our lids on but bike/car collisions will just carry one as per normal. As cyclists we should be outraged by this, but unfortunately too many cyclists have been brainwashed by the helmet mantra and just accept it.

  5. “he was there to uphold the law”

    What a lot of crap. In our over-regulated society, we have countless useless law ignored by everybody including the police. Most people don’t even know about them. They are a waste of space. So why pick this law?

    I got the feeling that this head police officer doesn’t like cyclists and has decided to pick on them. This is consistent with the attitude of the police in North Sydney who seem to disregard dangerous driving towards cyclists.

    Why is the police in the North Sydney area so much against cycling?

    Good to see that you got some warning and support from helmeted cyclists though. It shows that solidarity among cyclists is increasing.

  6. Good luck fighting the idiotic, anti-cycling and anti-environmentalist helmet law. I’d think one would die of heatstroke wearing those in the Austral summer. You have contacted Sue, I trust?

    I agree about the solidarity among cyclists – here in Montréal a while back they were ticketing cyclists who rode across a square instead of taking a very dangerous short stretch of road that was ONLY for right-turning vehicles, including a busy bus line, or riding to the left of the buses turning (of course turn those directions round for Oz and the UK). Some other cyclists warned me so I could get off and walk.

    In many places there are archaic laws still on the books forbidding “shirtlessness” or women wearing hems more than two inches above the ground etc. An archaic-law day could be a good exposure of such absurdities.

    They are choosing to enforce this law as an easy cash cow, with a very non-dangerous set of “scofflaws” to target.

  7. […] Here we go again.  It seems the nonsensical police crackdown on dangerous cycling scofflaws is still in […]

  8. Nice posting, I subsribe your feed. Keep it up with fresh idea.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.
Entries and comments feeds.

%d bloggers like this: